|
PREVENTION OF THE IRAQ WAR-ASSOCIATED SICKNESS
(I-WAS):
A Prediction and a Challenge to the Department of Defense
I dedicate this column to the courageous and valiant women and men who fought
and/or are fighting the Iraq War. Many of them are sick now. Many more will
become sick with passing months, and will remain so for years to come. I predict
that a large fraction of them will be disabled for many years. That is sad
because I believe most of that sickness is preventable. However, it cannot be
prevented with antidepressants, anxiolytic agents, broad-spectrum antibiotics,
or talk therapy. To be effective, the sick veterans will have to be managed with
a new model based on solid scientific knowledge concerning the dysfunctional
cellular energetics—redox dysequilibrium and oxygen dyshomeostasis—in the
chronically ill veterans caused by the growing burden of incremental and
functional nutritional deficits, environmental toxins, and stress-related
issues.
I could not have made the above prediction of disabling disorder of cellular
energetics in the 2004 Iraq War veterans except in light of experience with the
veterans of the 1991 conflict in the Persian Gulf. In 1991, while writing
The Canary and Chronic Fatigue, I saw a flash picture of the Kuwait oil field in
smoke and recognized two things clearly: first, that many returning veterans
will develop a largely preventable chronic illness; and second, that illness
will be chalked up to a psychosomatic disorder and the sick veterans will be
prescribed antidepressants, anxiolytic drugs, and talk therapy —measures that
provide temporary relief but mask the worsening deeper problem of seriously
disrupted cellular energetics. I devoted a few pages to my sense of that
upcoming disaster in Canary.1
TERROR TURNS INTO TOXICITY, TOXICITY INTO TERROR
My warning in Canary about the Gulf War veterans went unheeded. Why? Because the
experts of the Department of Defense (DOD) were unable to reach beyond the old
and obsolete one- cause/one-disease/one-drug model of thinking. They could
not—or did not want to—accept a simple fact of human biology: At a cellular
level, terror turns into toxicity, and toxicity into terror. Both terror and
toxicity feed on each other, and cumulatively lead to cellular oxidosis,
acidosis, and dysoxygenosis.2-5 It is important to point out that I did not find
a single reference to severe and persisting derangements of redox equilibrium
and oxygen homeostasis in the sick veterans of the 1991 war in hundreds of
reports on the subject. Needless to say, psychological evaluations were not an
acceptable substitute for laboratory tests to detect crucial defects in cellular
energetics. Nor were the prescriptions for sleeping pills, anxiolytic drugs,
antidepressants, and talk therapy satisfactory responses to deepening energy and
immune crises of the sick veterans.
THE CHALLENGE
In this column I challenge the DOD to consider a proposal for the prevention of
the Iraq War-associated sickness ("I-WAS") based on an energetic-molecular model
of chronic disabling illness focused on solid scientific evidence for redox
dysequilibrium and oxygen dyshomeostasis seen in persons with intracellular
accumulation of toxic substances—metabolites of the Krebs cycle, products of
impaired hepatic detoxification pathways, mycotoxins,
mitochondrial uncouplers,
and others.6-9 Why should the DOD consider my proposal for this clinical trial?
I ask the DOD to consider the following three quotes, one from Navy News and two
from The New York Times:
1995: Navy News:
Gulf War Syndrome—Who's Addressing the Issue? Long before the first veterans
returned from the Persian Gulf Dr. Majid Ali, associate professor of pathology
at the College of Physicians and Surgeons at Columbia University in New York,
predicted five outcomes: (1) That a large number of service men and women in the
Persian Gulf region would return with a variety of chronic environmental, immune
and stress-related problems; (2) The disabling fatigue would be a dominant
clinical feature while other symptoms would include recurrent infection, food
allergy reactions, abdominal problems, disorders of mood and memory, and skin
rashes, among others; (3) That sick veterans would initially be dismissed as
malingerers and labeled with various psychiatric diagnoses and prescribed large
doses of mind- numbing drugs; (4) That the chronic health disorders of these
veterans would worsen with multiple drug therapies; and (5) That when everything
else failed, these veterans would be prescribed long-term broad-spectrum
antibiotic therapy that would play further havoc with their bowel systems. Five
years later these predictions are now observable facts. Headlines debate the
cause and fate of those men and women who left healthy and returned home
sick—nearly 75,000 at last count. (Navy News, September 13, 1995)
1996: The New York Times:
Current evidence does not support a causal link between the symptoms of
chronically ill veterans of the 1991 war in the Persian Gulf. (Report of the
President's Advisory Committee to President Clinton, quoted by The New York
Times, October 15, 2004)
2004: The New York Times:
Chemicals Sickened Gulf War Veterans, Latest Study Finds: A federal panel of
medical experts studying illnesses among veterans of the 1991 war in the Persian
Gulf has broken with several earlier studies and concluded that many suffer from
neurological damage caused by exposure to toxic chemicals, rejecting past
findings that the ailments resulted mostly from wartime stress . . . the
Research Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans' Illnesses concluded in its
draft report that "a substantial proportion of Gulf war veterans are ill with
multisymptom conditions not explained by wartime stress or psychiatric illness."
(The New York Times, front page, October 15, 2004)
NO TO $5 MILLION FOR THE SICK, YES TO $450 MILLION FOR THE SYNDROME
Truth was systematically perverted during discussions of the Gulf War syndrome.
Stated bluntly, the health and lives of the sick veterans were sacrificed at the
altar of the pseudoscience of the one-disease/one-cause/one-drug model of the
prevailing medical thought. Am I being melodramatic? Consider the following
three quotes from the prestigious science journal Nature concerning the issue:
Nature, October 19, 2000 (page 819):
Desperately seeking a syndrome--The US Congress should stop pushing researchers
to invent a medical definition for Gulf War syndrome, the collection of maladies
associated with veterans of the 1991 conflict in the Persian Gulf.
Nature, March 8, 2001 (page 135):
Fracas over $5 million Gulf syndrome grant. The battle over Gulf War syndrome
has broken out again . . . this time over a US $5 million grant. The funding has
been granted without peer review, to the laboratory of clinician Robert Haley,
whose research on veterans is controversial. Ross Perot...Hutchinson's action.
"Those goofballs in the Pentagon are trying to just sell stress [as the cause of
Gulf War illness] and not do anything for the men," he says.
Nature, July 4, 2002
On 25 June, an advisory panel appointed by veterans' affairs secretary Anthony
Principi concluded that research into whether neurological damage had been
caused by vaccination or exposure to nerve agents "should be aggressively
pursued," and recommended that Congress commit $450 million over three years to
the project.
EAGER AND READY TO MEET THE VETERANS' MEDICAL NEEDS
Today is Veteran's Day, November 11, 2004. This morning on CNN, the Secretary of
Veterans' Affairs assures the nation that the VA hospital system is eager and
ready to meet all the medical needs of all Iraq War veterans. What does he
mean?, I wondered. In hundreds of the conferences of nutritionist-physicians and
clinical ecologists I have attended during the last twenty- five years, I do not
recall meeting any physician working in the VA hospital system. Nor am I aware
of nutritional or detox therapies administered in that system. So how is the VA
system eager and ready to serve the Iraq War veterans? I do not know anyone in
the VA system who is seriously addressing—even merely writing about—the crucial
issues of expanded nutritional and detoxification needs of the sick veterans.
Does the Secretary mean that those veterans have no special nutritional or detox
needs?
An hour later, while driving to the Institute, I heard a Florida Congressman, an
Iraq War veteran, pronounce that he is not aware of any unmet medical needs of
the veterans. When probed by the host, he conceded that he knew of some veterans
who had emotional problems, but in his view those problems probably existed
before the veterans went to Iraq. Like the Secretary, the Congressman was
unburdened by any knowledge of how terror and toxicity at cellular levels cause
massive loss of essential nutrients, and how toxic organic acids build rapidly
in the cells under the conditions of redox dysequilibrium and oxygen
dyshomeostasis.
The Secretary and that Congressman seem not to have any memory of how chronic
illness and cancers in the Vietnam veterans caused by Agent Orange and related
chemicals were ignored for several years. Nor do they seem to recall any of the
much larger tragedy of the Gulf War syndrome, recently acknowledged by the DOD,
reported by The New York Times, and referenced earlier in this column.
No, the VA system is neither eager nor ready to meet the special nutritional and
detoxification needs of the sick veterans of the Iraq War. I fervently hope
someone at the DOD will give some thought to the merit of the proposal in this
article and be open to the possibility of preventing another major disaster.
WHO SHOULD EXPRESS OPINION ON DYSFUNCTIONAL CELLULAR ENERGETICS?
Surgeons let pathologists express opinions on biopsy materials. Cardiologists
let pulmonologists express opinion on matters of chronic lung disorders.
Gastroenterologists refrain from passing judgment on the work of
rheumatologists. In the case of the Gulf War syndrome, it was curious—and
tragic—that the DOD allowed those with no training in the laboratory evaluation
of the status of redox equilibrium and oxygen homeostasis to pass judgment on
whether or not the chronically ill veterans suffered from cellular toxicity,
respiratory-to-fermentative shift in ATP production, and other forms of
functional cellular derangements. That grievous error led to the tragic neglect
of the sick veterans for nearly fourteen years. The central tragedy of the
medical injustice done to the chronically ill veterans of the Gulf War was that
their varying symptom- complexes were attributed to psychological abnormalities
without making an effort to uncover the sources of toxic exposures. The veterans
paid a huge price for the ignorance of those who were required to provide sound
medical advice. I have no doubt that a similar fate will befall veterans of the
Iraq War who are being 'treated' by 'medical experts' who neither learn the
biochemistry of systemic toxicity, nor have any interest in detoxification
strategies.
In the past columns, I have furnished data about toxicity caused by
respiratory-to- fermentative shift, hepatic overload of chemicals, and
mycotoxicosis. Here, I include a case history of severe toxicity reaction
arising from a source that is overlooked nearly universally, except by a handful
of clinicians. A 43-year-old woman presented with severe fatigue and myalgia;
orthostatic intolerance; difficulties of mood, memory, and mentation; and
environmental sensitivities. An analysis of 24-hour urinary excretion of organic
acids revealed increased excretion of Krebs cycle metabolites, indicating the
existence of respiratory-to-fermentative shift. She showed a moderate initial
response to our initial integrative oxystatic management plan. Then she
underwent dental work and suffered a severe relapse of all of her symptoms and
developed cardiac rhythm disorder, which necessitated hospitalization. Following
an extensive diagnostic work-up, she was discharged with a diagnosis of
tachycardia of unknown cause. Some days later, I received a call from her
primary physician, who thought her problems were supratentorial and she needed
psychotherapy. Then he asked me if I would support his decision.
|
Table 1.
Severe
Inhibition of Crucial Enzymes of Cellular Energetics by Toxins
from Dental Cavitation and Tooth Materials |
|
|
Percent Inhibition |
|
Enzyme |
Soft Tissue* |
Tooth |
|
Creatine kinase |
98.9 |
97.6 |
|
Phosphoglycerate
kinase |
98.2 |
86.9 |
|
Phosphorylase
kinase |
97.3 |
87.4 |
|
Phosphorylase A |
96.8 |
88.9 |
|
Pyruvate kinase |
95.5 |
87.8 |
|
Adenylate kinase
|
92.6 |
66.9 |
|
Average |
97 |
86 |
*Cavitation biopsy tissues.
In Table 1, I present data revealing the real
source of toxic exposure that destabilized her and led to hospitalization. Note
the severe—in some cases near total—suppression of enzymes with crucial roles in
cellular energetics by factors (mostly microbial toxins) released from the
tissues surrounding dental cavitation and other parts of dead or dying teeth.
The laboratory range of suppression of those enzymes in nontoxic subjects was
less than five percent. How many cardiologists or internists in the country,
might one ask, have been trained or are even aware of this source of serious and
potentially life-threatening toxicity?
What does dental toxicity have to do with I-WAS? My essential point in the above
case history is this: Those unfamiliar with clinical and laboratory diagnosis of
cellular toxicity should not be permitted to dismiss Iraq War veterans as mere
psychosomatic problems. The second reason for including the above case study is
to underscore the point that integrative physicians diligently search for causes
of cellular toxicity— mycotoxins, excess Krebs cycle metabolites, heavy metals,
mitochondrial uncouplers, and others—which most mainstream doctors do not even
think about.
A PROPOSAL FOR A CLINICAL TRIAL FOR THE IRAQ WAR VETERANS
Looking back, the experience with the Agent Orange-related sickness in Vietnam
veterans and the Gulf War syndrome among veterans of the Persian Gulf conflict
makes it abundantly clear that the one- disease/one-cause/one-drug model of the
prevailing pharmacologic medicine neither provided us any understanding of the
true nature of the veterans' chronic sickness, nor did it solve their medical
problems. In the proposed clinical trial, I submit that the Oxygen Model be
applied for the clinical evaluation and management of the unwell veterans. I
described the Oxygen Model at length in Integrative Nutritional Medicine—Looking
Through the Prism of Oxygen Homeostasis, the fifth volume of The Principles and
Practice of Integrative Medicine.
The Goal of the Proposed Clinical Trial
The goal of the clinical trial will be to determine by true-to-life, long-term
follow-up study whether or not optimal nutritional, detox, and self-regulatory
measures can prevent the development of chronic debilitating illness among the
Iraq War veterans, as it happened to a large number of Gulf War veterans.
Subjects of the Clinical Trial
I propose that four hundred veterans of the Iraq War who state they are not as
healthy one year after their service as they were before that should be entered
in the clinical trial, to be conducted by the DOD as follows: (1) one-half of
that veterans cohort be taken from the Eastern USA and be assigned to ten
university internists, who have the freedom to manage their cases according to
prevailing standards of laboratory testing and drug therapies of the
pharmacologic model; (2) the second half of the veterans be taken from the
Eastern USA and be assigned to ten integrative physicians, who are given freedom
to evaluate the redox equilibrium and oxygen homeostasis of the veterans with
established laboratory methods, and then manage their cases according to the
accepted nutritional, detoxification, and self-regulatory approaches; (3) the
trial be conducted for three years; and (4) the outcome of the study be decided
by using predetermined clinical and laboratory criteria.
Two Entry Criteria for the DOD Trial
I propose that the following two sets of criteria for establishing the presence
of I-WAS be established:
1. A set of clinical criteria that depends on self-evaluation of chronically
unwell veterans. This criteria would be considered met when a veteran reports
steady deterioration in health during the year after the tour of duty—including
recurrent infections; disabling fatigue; tissue pain; the problems of mood,
memory, and mentation; and sexual dysfunctions. Simply stated, the criterion
would be met if a veteran utters the words "I am not what I was," for the
purpose of this study; and
2. A set of biochemical criteria that assesses oxygen homeostasis, redox
dynamics, and acid-base equilibrium. Specifically, it should include
measurements of urinary excretion of metabolites of the Krebs cycle, the
increased levels of which show incontrovertible evidence for disruption of
cellular oxygen homeostasis (see Townsend Letter of July/August 2004 for a large
body of data concerning the respiratory-to-fermentative shift in chronic energy
deficit states).
The Clinical Trial Outcome
The outcome of the study will be assessed at six-month intervals for three years
employing predetermined clinical and laboratory parameters. The clinical
parameters will include: (1) an overall sense of well-being; (2) quality of work
at the place of employment; (3) level of energy/fatigue; (4) frequency and
degree of pain states; (5) quality of mood, memory, and mentation; (6) quality
of sleep; (7) digestive-absorptive functions; (8) sexual health; (9) frequency
of infections and frequency of antibiotic use; and (10) the use of
antidepressants, anxiolytic agents, and sleep medications. The laboratory
parameters will focus on issues of oxygen homeostasis, redox dynamics, and
acid-base equilibrium.
In essence, the study will focus on the energetic-molecular basis of health and
disease, and not on the prevailing ideas of disease classifications. I believe
such an approach is essential if we are to avoid the massive tragedy of the Gulf
War syndrome.
THE OXYGEN PROTOCOL
Oxygen Protocol is my term for a clinical plan for preserving or restoring
oxygen homeostasis for achieving long-term optimal health and disease
prevention. The focus on the Oxygen Protocol is not on disease classifications,
early diagnosis of specific diseases, or the use of agents that block cellular
receptors, channels, pumps, and mediators of healing responses—as is the case in
the prevailing model of pharmacologic medicine. Rather, the Oxygen Protocol
focuses on optimizing cellular energetics by focusing on the molecular-energetic
dynamics of the health/dis-ease/disease continuum. I discussed the scientific
basis and the clinical rationale of the Oxygen Protocol (including dosage
schedules of specific measures) at length in Nature's Preoccupation With
Complementarity and Contrariety, Dysoxygenosis and Oxystatic Therapies, and
Integrative Nutritional Medicine—Looking Through the Prism of Oxygen
Homeostasis, the first, third, and fifth volumes of The Principles and Practice
of Integrative Medicine.0-12 In Figure 1, I reproduce a schema from
Dysoxygenosis and Oxystatic Therapies that shows my clinical priorities
addressing macroecologic tissue-organ and microecologic cellular systems for
preserving and achieving oxygen homeostasis.
Figure 1. S chematic
Representation of the Trio of Trios of Human Ecosystems for Establishing
Clinical Priorities for Preserving and/or Restoring Oxygen Homeostasis
The integrative management plans individualized to serve the specific needs of
individual patients—focusing on optimal nutritional support, hepato-enteric
detoxification, and self-regulation—cannot be standardized in the fashion of
drug regimens. Below, I outline integrative redox-restorative and oxystatic
therapies that have been validated by extended clinical use at the Institute as
guidelines for designing individualized plans for individual veterans.
In writing The Canary and Chronic Fatigue, my primary purpose was to address the
one question that had preoccupied me for several years: How can one restore the
functionalities of the enzyme systems of the human energetic and detoxification
pathways? How can one create microecologic conditions in which energy enzymes
can regenerate, so to speak? One day I saw the flash image in which the word
"energy" stood for:
Environment
Nutrition
Exercise
Restoration (of energy enzyme pathways)
God
You
My colleagues at the Institute and I have cared for nearly 8,000 patients with
chronic energy and immune deficit states since the writing of The Canary.
Extended long-term clinical follow-up results obtained with the above "ENERGY"
model have fully validated the clinical efficacy of that approach. The core
therapeutic elements of that model are briefly outlined below:
Environment, Internal and External
In clinical medicine, as elsewhere in life, no part can be understood except
through its relationship with the whole. This must be accepted as one of the
core tenets in all discussions of I-WAS. In this context, the suffering of the
chronically ill Iraq War veterans must be examined in light of altered
conditions in their internal environment—tissue-organ macroecology and cellular
microecology—as well as external environment. Specifically, it must include:
1. Effective management of issues of the bowel, blood, and liver ecosystems;
2. A systematic search for the sources of environmental toxins—mycotoxins, toxic
metals, pesticides and herbicides, air and water pollutants, and others—that
affect individual patients; and
3. Antigen immunotherapy for IgE-mediated responses.
I discussed the above issues at length in the sixth and seventh volumes of The
Principles and Practice of Integrative Medicine.13,14
Nutrition
The theoretical and clinical aspects of nutritional therapies have been
presented at length in Integrative Nutritional Medicine. There are, of course,
many other excellent volumes devoted to this subject which can be used for
establishing broad standards of care for the proposed clinical trial. Below, I
briefly list the nutrients that require special focus in an integrative
management plan for restoring the health of veterans with Gulf War syndrome (and
now with I-WAS).
1. Minerals: magnesium, potassium, calcium, zinc, selenium, chromium, and
molybdenum;
2. Vitamins: vitamins A, B complex, C, D, E, and K;
3. Sulfur-containing redox-restorative factors: glutathione, taurine,
methylsulfonylmethane, lipoic acid, and N-acetyl-L-cysteine;
4. Miscellaneous nutrients: coenzyme Q10,phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylcholine;
5. Parenteral nutrient support: see Tables 2-4 for examples of two intramuscular
and one intravenous protocol.
|
Table
2. INTRAMUSCULAR PROTOCOL A |
|
Nutrient |
Concentration |
Volume |
|
Magnesium Sulfate |
500 mg/ml |
1.5 ml |
|
Calcium Gly/lac |
10 mg/ml |
1.5 ml |
|
Vitamin B12 |
10,000 mcg/ml |
0.5 ml |
|
Vit.B Complex |
* |
1 ml |
|
Pantothenic Acid |
250 mg/ml |
0.5 ml |
|
Pyridoxin |
100 mg/ml |
0.5 ml |
|
Zinc |
5 mg/ml |
0.6 ml |
|
Molybdenum |
25 mcg/ml |
0.5 ml |
|
Selenium |
40 mcg/ml |
0.4 ml |
|
Multivitamin
|
** |
0.5 ml |
|
Table 3. INTRAMUSCULAR
PROTOCOL B |
|
Nutrient |
Concentration |
Volume |
|
Magnesium Sulfate |
500 mg/ml |
3 ml |
|
Calcium Gly/lac |
10 mg/ml |
4 ml |
|
Vitamin B12 |
10,000 mcg/ml |
0.5 ml |
|
Table 4.
INTRAVENOUS PROTOCOL |
|
Nutrient |
Conc=Volume |
Amount |
|
Vitamin C |
500 mg/ml=40 ml |
20 gm |
|
Vitamin A |
**=20 ml |
6,600 IU |
|
Vitamin D |
" |
400 IU |
|
Vitamin E |
" |
20 IU |
|
Biotin |
" |
120 mcg |
|
Folic Acid |
" |
800 mcg |
|
Niacinamide |
" |
80 mg |
|
Riboflavin |
" |
7.2 mg |
|
Thiamine |
" |
6 mg |
|
Pantothenic Acid |
250 mg/ml=2 ml |
530 mg |
|
Pyridoxine |
100 mg/ml=1 ml |
108 mg |
|
Cyanocobalamine*(see
below) |
1,000 mcg/ml=2.5 ml |
2,500 mcg |
|
Taurine |
50 mg/ml=1 ml |
50 mg |
|
Calcium Gly/lac |
10 mg/ml=12.5 ml |
125 mg |
|
Copper Sulfate |
***=8 ml |
3.2 mg |
|
Chromium |
" |
32 mcg |
|
Magnesium Sulfate |
500 mg/ml=4 ml |
2,000 mg |
|
Manganese |
***= |
0.8 mg |
|
Molybdenum |
25 mcg/ml=4 ml |
100 mcg |
|
Zinc Sulfate |
5 mg/ml=4 ml |
28 mg |
|
Selenium |
40 mcg/ml=5 ml |
200 mcg |
|
Glutathione |
200 mg/ml |
3 ml |
|
Taurine |
500 mg/ml |
4 ml |
|
Vitamin B12 |
10,000 mcg/ml |
0.5 ml |
Rheologic Agents: As in the
Basic Protocol
Solution: As in the Basic
Protocol
*Cyanocobalamine is given as
an IM injection (1 ml)
Administration Time: 75 to
120 minutes
Exercise
Physical
exercise is essential for health preservation and recovery from chronic energy
and immune deficit disorders. However, in energy deficit states associated with
respiratory-to-fermentative shift, commonly used routines for exercise cause a
rapid buildup of organic acids within cells and increase fatigue. In Ghoraa
and Limbic Exercise,15
I provide specific information for noncompetitive exercise with mini breaks to
prevent cellular acidosis.
Restoration of Enzymes of
Cellular Energetic and Detoxification Pathways
The following therapies
are valuable in addressing the problem of respiratory-to-fermentative shift in
ATP production characteristically seen in Gulf War syndrome-like states.
. Direct oxystatic therapies: (a) oxygen by mask; (b) hydrogen peroxide
foot soaks; and (c) hydrogen peroxide or ozone infusions;
2. Indirect oxystatic therapies addressing the bowel issues: (a)
probiotic formula composed of approximately one
billion spores of Lactobacillus acidophilus, Lactobacillus bulgaricus,
and Bifidobacterium in a suitable base of complex vegetable fiber; and
(b) herbal formulas in weekly rotation (author's preferences include echinacea,
astragalus, burdock root, goldenseal, artemisia, pau d'arco, and beet root
fiber);
3. Indirect oxystatic therapies addressing the hepatic detoxification
issues: (a) lecithin; (b) castor oil liver packs; (c) liver flushes (with lemon
juice, olive oil, and cayenne); and (d) hepatoprotective herbs (author's
preferences include milk thistle, turmeric, Jerusalem artichoke, ginger, garlic,
and spirolina).
God
In my experience,
mere clichés do not suffice for coping with heavy burdens imposed on oxygen
homeostasis by terror turning into toxicity, and toxicity into terror. The way
out of unrelenting suffering cannot be found without redefining the link that
binds us to the gentle, sustaining energy of the Presence that permeates
each of us at all times—finding one's own divinity, so to speak. What is
required is a wellspring of hope arising from deep within. I present some of my
clinical observations in Healing, Miracles and the Bite of the Gray Dog.16
You
When dealing with
chronically ill patients who do not respond to ordinary drug regimens, we
physicians, in general, are deeply troubled by subjects of self-regulation,
states of consciousness, and spirituality. That is ironic because the sick
nearly always welcome opportunities to explore those areas. I do not speak here
of esoteric brands of mysticism. Gurus are not necessary. Good teachers will
do. But none of that can be done without the patient being an equal partner in
the journey of healing. I present a personal perspective on this subject in
What Do Lions Know About Stress?17
CLOSING COMMENTS
During the early
1990s, many in the Department of Defense had hoped that the thorny issue of the
Gulf War syndrome will simply go away with passing years. It did not. As cited
earlier, on June 25, 2002, the Secretary for Veterans' Affairs recommended that
Congress commit $450 million over three years to the study of neurologic damage
to the veterans of the 1991 Persian Gulf conflict. Now I see another looming
national tragedy—the
Iraq-War-Associated Illness (I-WAS)—and
another long period of denial of the cellular energetic and toxicity issues that
confront the present generation of veterans. Will they continue to be neglected
as were the chronically ill veterans of the Gulf War before them? Will their
suffering be also chalked up to stress? Will the medical care they receive be
confined to prescriptions of sleeping pills, anxiolytics, and antidepressants,
as was the case with persons suffering from the Gulf War syndrome? Will more
salt be poured on their cellular wounds—their leaky cell membranes, uncoupled
mitochondria, and blocked Krebs cycles, by offering them talk therapy?
Or will the department of
Defense be open to considering the following crucial questions:
1. Why do 140,000 of the total of 693,000 women and men who went to the
Gulf conflict fourteen years ago continue to be partially or fully disabled?
2.
2. Why did the Department exclude
from the care of the sick veterans clinicians who had published extensively
about effective therapies for restoration of redox equilibrium and oxygen
dyshomeostasis in chronic illness identical to that suffered by the veterans?
3.
3. What lessons learned from the
Gulf War syndrome may be applied to prevent similar disaster happening to
veterans of the Iraq War?
4.
4. What possible justification
exists for caring for the chronically ill Iraq war veterans with the same old
one-disease/one-cause/one-drug dogma of medicine that failed so completely in
the case of the sick Gulf War veterans?
I hope some at
the Department will have the courage to consider this challenge.
Reference
1. Ali M. The Canary and Chronic Fatigue, 1st ed. 1994. Denville, New
Jersey, Life Span Books, pp 58-65.
2. Ali M. Darwin, fatigue, and fibromyalgia. J Integrative Medicine
1999;3:5-10.
3. Ali
M. Darwin, oxidosis, dysoxygenosis, and integration. J Integrative
Medicine 1999;3: 11-16.
4.
Ali M. Fibromyalgia: an oxidative‑ dysoxygenative disorder (ODD). J
Integrative Medicine 1999;3:17-37.
5. Ali M. Oxidative-dysoxygenative
parasympathetic dystrophy: frequency of diminished high-frequency
parasympathetic outflow in subjects with chronic oxidosis and dysoxygenosis.
J Integrative Medicine
2002;6:101-107.
6. Ali M.
Respiratory-to-fermentative
(RTF) shift in ATP production in chronic energy deficit states. Townsend
Letter for Doctors and Patients, August/Sept. 2004, pp. 64-65.
7. Ali M. September Eleven, 2005.
New York, Aging Healthfully Books, 2003.
8. He W, Milao F J-P, Lin D C-H, et al.
Citric acid cycle
intermediates as ligands for orphan G-protein-coupled receptors.
Nature
2004;429:188-193.
9.
Herbert SC. Orphan detectors of metabolism. Nature 2004;429:143-145.
10.
Ali M. The Principles and Practice of
Integrative Medicine Volume I: Nature's Preoccupation With Complementarity
and Contrariety. 2000. Washington, D.C. Capital University Press (in
collaboration with Canary 21 Press, New York) www.Canary21press. com.
11.
Ali M. The Principles
and Practice of Integrative Medicine Volume III: Dysoxygenosis and
Oxystatic Therapies. 2003. Washington, D.C. Capital University Press (in
collaboration with Canary 21 Press, New York) www.Canary21press.com.
12.
Ali M. Integrative
Nutritional Medicine: Nutrition Seen Through the Prism of Oxygen
Homeostasis. 2003. Washington, D.C. Capital University Press (in
collaboration with Canary 21 Press, New York) www.Canary21press.com.
13.
Ali M. Integrative
Immunology and Allergy. 2002. Heavy Metal Load and Toxicity:
Mercury‑Induced Dysoxygenosis. 2003. Washington, D.C. Capital University
Press (in collaboration with Canary 21 Press, New York) www.Canary21press.
com.
14.
Ali M. Heavy Metal
Load and Toxicity: Mercury‑Induced Dysoxygenosis. 2003. Washington,
D.C. Capital University Press (in collaboration with Canary 21 Press, New
York) www.Canary21press. com.
15. Ali M. The Ghoraa and Limbic
Exercise. 1993. Denville, New Jersey, Life Span Books.
16. Ali M: Healing, Miracles, and the
Bite of the Gray Dog,. 1997. Denville, New Jersey, Life Span Books.
17.
Ali M: What Do Lions Know About Stress? 1996. Denville, New Jersey,
Life Span Books
|