|
The
Journal of Integrative Medicine |
Ali M, Ali O. AA Oxidopathy: the core pathogenetic mechanism
of ischemic heart disease. J Integrative Medicine 1997;1:1-112.
AA Oxidopathy:
The Core Pathogenetic Mechanism of Ischemic Heart Disease
Majid Ali, M.D., Omar Ali, M.D.
Page 3 of 11
MORPHOLOGY OF ATHEROSCLEROSIS By gross morphology, atherosclerosis is a simple process that progresses in
three stages. In the first stage, a yellow-gray fatty streak appears on the inner surface
of the vessel wall. Histologically, it comprises foamy, lipid-laden macrophages in the
subendothelial space. The second stage is characterized by a fibrous plaque formation. The
plaque is composed of a central necrotic, acellular area of fatty deposits covered by a
fibrous cap, which in reality is made up of proliferating myocytes and fibroblasts in a
matrix of collagen. In the third stage, hemorrhage occurs within the central necrotic
area, resulting in a thrombus composed of fibrin threads with trapped platelets. The
smooth fatty streak is often present in children and progresses to the two later stages
with time.
The common atheromatous plaque is a raised area of white-gray-yellow
discoloration on the inside wall of a vessel. As plaque grows in size, it protrudes into
the vascular lumen and begins to reduce the inner caliber of the vessel. Plaques may vary
in size from 0.1 to 2 cm in diameter, but may grow to much larger sizes when they
coalesce. In the aorta and larger arteries, plaques may extend for several centimeters.
The luminal surfaces of plaques are usually irregular and indurated; small erosions
covered with fibrin thrombi are commonly observed. On section, the center of large plaques
often exudes viscous, yellow-gray-brown gummous materialhence, the name atheroma
from the Greek word for gruel. Histologically, plaques are composed of necrotic tissue
with cholesterol crystals and other lipid deposits, degeneration and necrosis of the
collagen and the muscle in the vascular wall, smooth muscle proliferation, and fibrous
scarring at the periphery of the plaque. In advanced stages, hemorrhage and dystrophic
calcification frequently occur in necrotic tissues.
It is the presence of cholesterol crystals and other lipid deposits in
the plaque that has misled generations of pathologists and cardiologists into thinking
that cholesterol is the cause of atherosclerosisjust as a prior generation of
pathologists made a similar error in mistaking deposits of dystrophic calcification in
injured tissues as evidence for dysregulated calcium metabolism. In atherosclerosis,
cholesterol deposits occur as a consequence of oxidative coagulopathy, just as calcium
deposits are often seen in organized hematomas. As we mention briefly in the abstract of
this paper and discuss at length below, cholesterol is an antioxidant and cannot cause the
lesions of coronary artery disease that are produced as a result of oxidative injury.
MORPHOLOGIC
PATTERNS OF AA OXIDOPATHY Below we describe our high-resolution, phase-contrast morphologic
observations that comprise AA oxidopathy and oxidative coagulopathy. The degree and extent
of oxidative changes, of course, varies over a broad range depending on the number and the
nature of oxidative stressors. During the early months of our work with AA oxidopathy, we
were concerned with the issue of whether the changes we observed involving the
erythrocytes, granulocytes, platelets and plasma occurred in the circulating blood or were
they artifacts caused by the process of preparing peripheral blood smears. We carefully
examined fresh smears of several hundreds of apparently healthy individuals who sought our
preventive medicine servicesas well as those of many healthy volunteersto
assess the range of such morphologic changes in health. Thus, we were able to confidently
differentiate semiquantitatively rather limited morphologic changes sometimes seen in
healthy subjects from the frequently observed and pronounced abnormalities involving
erythrocytes, platelets and plasma encountered in AA oxidopathy in a host of
cardiovascular and noncardiovascular clinicopathologic entities.
In the context of IHD, important oxidant stressors include
hyperadrenergic state, smoking, hyperglycemia, excess oxidized plasma lipids, obesity and
cardiac arrhythmias. We have microscopically microscopically coagulopathy within the
circulating blood to generally progress in the following seven morphologic stages:
1. Erythrocyte and leukocyte membrane deformities 2. Diaphanous congealing of plasma 3. Platelet aggregation and lysis 4. Filamentous coagulum (fibrin needles) 5. Lumpy coagulum
6. Microclots 7. Microplaques
The patterns of oxidative coagulative injury described in this article were observed in extensive studies of blood
morphology in a host of acute and chronic cardiovascular as well as non-cardiovascular
disorders, including advanced IHD, unstable angina, congestive heart failure, cardiac
arrhythmias, hypertensive crises, acute and chronic viral and bacterial infections,
fungemia, acute and chronic atopic disorders, chemical sensitivity reactions, acute and
chronic degenerative disorders and malignant diseases.
Erythrocyte Membrane Damage and Lysis
in AA Oxidopathy Erythrocytes, when observed with an ordinary bright-light microscope in
stained smears of peripheral blood, appear as rigid, biconcave, disc-shaped corpuscles.
When examined with a high-resolution, phase-contrast microscope in freshly prepared
unstained smears, these cells are seen as pliable, round cells that readily change their
shape to ovoid, triangular, dumbbell, or irregular outlines to squeeze past other
erythrocytes in densely populated fields. Such cells resume their regular rounded contour
as soon as they find open space.
Erythrocytes may be expected to show evidence of oxidative damage
earlier than other blood corpuscles since these cells transport oxygen, the most important
oxidizer in the body. Furthermore, unlike the leukocyte cell membrane which is sturdy and
uniquely equipped with enzymatic antioxidant defenses against oxidative stresses of
microbial invaders, the erythrocyte membrane is more permeable (to facilitate oxygen
uptake and delivery) and, hence, may be deemed more vulnerable. Our microscopic findings
provide some evidence for such theoretical considerations. The earliest and most common
abnormalities we observed in AA oxidopathy are erythrocyte membrane irregularities and
cell deformities. As oxidopathy progresses, an increasing number of red cells show
morphologic abnormalities and some cells appear as ghost outlines. Many erythrocytes show
surface wrinkling, teardrop deformity, sharp angulations and spike formations. Other
changes include rouleaux formations and zones of plasma congealing around damaged
erythrocytes.. Some zones of plasma congealing sometimes appear to form spontaneously
(without a discernable cause) in close vicinity of damaged erythrocytes and leukocytes.
We established the oxidative nature of plasma and cellular
abnormalities described above by demonstrating their reversibility with antioxidants such
as vitamin E, taurine, vitamin A, and vitamin C, reported previously12 but not
shown here. Parenthetically, we add that we have observed similar evidence of erythrocyte
membrane injury in diverse clinical entities associated with accelerated molecular injury
such as disabling chronic fatigue,
fibromyalgia and a host of severe nutritional, ecologic
and autoimmune disorders.
Erythrocyte Homogenate, Free Iron and AA
Oxidopathy In deliberations of atherogenesis, the issues of oxidative injury to
erythrocytes and the presence in the plasma of free hemoglobin leached from damaged red
cellsand the presence of excess iron in the plasma as a result of those
factorsare seldom, if ever, addressed. Our morphologic findings lead us to propose
that oxidative erythrocyte injury plays an important role in the genesis of AA oxidopathy
and, hence, atherogenesis. We observed erythrocyte membrane damage and lysis with high
frequency in many acute ischemic coronary syndromes and, less often, in patients with
advanced IHD but without severe, acute coronary ischemia.
Iron, like oxygen, is a molecular Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. It is needed
for molecular transport (in hemoglobin for oxygen), for storage (in myoglobin), for energy
functions (in cytochrome oxidase and other cytochromes), for respiration (in non-heme-iron
proteins), and for antioxidant defenses (in catalase). In its Mr. Hyde role, iron (in free
form) is a potent oxidant and catalyzes the generation of many dangerous oxygen-derived
radicals.175-182 In health, the Mr. Hyde roles of iron are minimized by
transferrin, an iron-binding protein that rigidly limits the availability of free iron. In
normal plasma, only 20 to 30 percent of transferrin occurs in a saturated state.
Free hemoglobin has been considered a dangerous proteina
biological Fenton catalyst.179 It rapidly quenches free radicals in a highly
oxidizing environment and becomes oxidized, thus turning into a potent oxidant. It is
readily degraded by H2O2 to release free iron, which initiates and propagates several free
radical reactions.182-183 Hemoglobin reacts with H2O2 to produce a
protein-bound oxidizing species capable of causing lipid peroxidation.184 Free
hemoglobin also avidly binds with nitric oxide radicals and induces vasospasm, triggering
yet other oxidizing events, which, in turn, feed the "oxidative fires" of AA
oxidopathy.
Beyond ample evidence of the destructive oxidizing capacity of
erythrocyte-derived factors discussed above, there is also direct evidence that red blood
cells play a role in atherogenesis. Sambrano et al.185 and colleagues have
shown that certain receptors on macrophages for oxidized LDL also bind to
oxidatively-injured red cells prior to their internalization and lysis.
Oxidatively-modified lipid, proteins, and carbohydrate moieties of erythrocyte membranes
can be expected to play a host of roles in oxidative coagulopathy and AA oxidopathy, just
as they do in attachment, endocytosis, membrane fusion, and viral hemagglutination in
viral infections.186-189 We may point out in this context, as shown by Oda et
al.189 that oxyradicals play the key pathogenetic roles in virus-induced
illness. As we discuss in Part II of this article, a growing body of evidence points to
the roles of strong inflammatory, infectious and autoimmune mechanisms in atherogenesis.
It seems obvious to us that additional evidence for inflammatory and immunogenic roles of
erythrocyte-derived factors in oxidative coagulopathy, AA oxidopathy, atherogenesis and
IHD will be forthcoming as those areas are explored further in the future. Of considerable
interest in this context is the matter of electrostatic interactions among oxidatively
damaged erythrocyte membranes and other oxidized elements in the circulating blood
ecosystem. Phospholipids and lipid components of LDL inhibit infectivity and
hemagglutination of rhabdoviruses, probably because of structural similarity between such
compounds and the receptors for viruses in cell membranes.190,191 In the case
of vesicular stomatitis virus, phosphatidylinositol, phosphatidylserine and GM3
ganglioside show inhibitory activity.192 What are the mechanisms of action of
such lipid moieties? Some light on this question is shed by studies of Mastromarino and
colleagues193 in which removal of negatively charged molecules from membrane
lipids by enzyme treatment significantly reduces their inhibitory activity, suggesting
that electrostatic interactions play important roles in viral cell membrane dynamics. It
seems highly likely that similar electrostatic roles involving platelets, monocytes and
other elements in circulating blood ecology will also be discovered in the future.
Granulocyte Clumping, Membrane Damage, and
Lysis in AA Oxidopathy The granulocyte is usually dismissed as inconsequential in discussions of
atherogenesis. This surprises us for two reason: 1) we observe morphologic evidence of
oxidative damage to granulocytes in AA oxidopathy with high frequency in patients with
IHD; 2) it is known that granulocytes produce toxic oxidative species that degrade other
intracellular and extracellular molecular species, inflict peroxidative injury to
cytoplasmic and organelle membranes, enhance polymorphonuclear leukocyte-endothelial
adhesion, and increase microvascular permeability.194-200 Evidently, all of
those factors can initiate, perpetuate and intensify oxidative phenomena that cause
oxidative coagulopathy and AA oxidopathy and may result in IHD. Some oxidizing molecular
species elaborated by granulocytes increase capillary permeability and enhance
granulocyte-endothelial adhesiveness.202 It seems odd to us that the cell known
to play initial and critical roles in oxidative tissue injury is ignored in conditions
characterized by oxidative injury to the circulating blood that results in atherogenesis.
We recognized that granulocytes would be found to play a central role in atherogenesis
when the molecular dynamics of this cell in atherogenesis are eventually investigated.
This, indeed, is beginning to happen.
The granulocyte, like the erythrocyte, is a victim of the current
infatuation of cholesterol enthusiasts with cholesterol. Our microscopic findings show
that granulocytes play pivotal roles in initiating and perpetuating oxidative cascades in
the circulating blood. In freshly prepared, unstained peripheral blood smears of healthy
subjects, we observe granulocytes as hunter cells that move like crabs on the ocean floor,
their locomotion provided by streaming of their granules into little protrusions of their
cytoplasm. These cells continuously change their shapes as they explore their
microenvironment. Not uncommonly, we visualize active phagocytosis of bacteria and
cellular debris by such cells. In AA oxidopathy, the earliest change involving
granulocytes is loss of locomotionthe cells lie limp in pools of plasma, with
diminished or absent granular streaming. In later stages, granulocytes exhibit clumping.
As in the case of erythrocytes, some granulocytes in more advanced cases of AA oxidopathy
show blurring of membranes while others appear as ghost outlines of cells. Eventually,
badly damaged granulocyte show disintegration of segments of their walls, degranulation
and lysis.
The cytoplasmic granules of human granulocytes are rich in many enzymes
including proteases, such as elastase, which are capable of degrading proteins in
intracellular as well extracellular fluids.202 Oxidative cell membrane injury
may be expected to result in escape of proteases from granulocytes into the circulating
blood. The destructive capacity of granulocytes represents an exaggerated physiologic
response in which bursts of potent oxidative molecular species are produced during
inflammatory and repair responses. Specifically, hydroxyl radical (OH.) derived from
superoxide radical (O2-) produced by granulocytes are a major cause of cellular injury.
Granulocytic myeloperoxidase generates hypochlorite radicals when exposed to H2O2
following phagocytic activation.203 Hypochlorite, in turn, oxidizes protease
inhibitors, thus leading to increased proteolytic tissue damage.
Granulocytes play a central role in the generation and function of
oxidative species that control cellular signaling, regulate mediators of inflammatory and
repair responses, and influence migration and replication of inflammatory cells.204-207
A spate of recent gene-activation studies show evidence of the involvement of granulocytes
in atherogenesis. Transcription of many atheroscleroses-related genes is augmented by
oxidant-sensitive regulatory pathways involving nuclear factor kB (NF-kB).207
Specifically, exposure to superoxide radicals produced in granulocytesand to lesser
degrees in other cellsactivates the NF-kB regulatory complex,206,207
which, in turn, triggers transcription of genes that encode for a variety of proteins
including leukocyte adhesion molecules, chemotactic cytokines and enzymes that regulate
cellular and matrix metabolism.207 Indirect evidence of the relevance of
granulocytic factors in coronary artery disease has been shown by Tanaka et al.204
who documented activation of vascular cells and leukocytes in the rabbit aorta after
balloon injury. Direct evidence for activation of NF-kB in experimental injury has
recently been shown by Lindner et al.209 Recent findings of Tardif et al.90
that probucol reduces the incidence of restenosis after coronary angioplasty is consistent
with such considerations, since the drug is a potent antioxidant and would be expected to
protect coronary arteries traumatized by the angioplasty procedure from granulocytic
oxidative bursts.
To continue with page 4 of
11 |